Posted by
Bill Crawford on Wednesday, April 22, 2009 12:53:26 AM
We not only recant and apologize to the world for torturing Al Queda's best, but we are leaving open the option of prosecuting Bush officials for authorizing it.
I won't even get into how the Geneva Convention doesn't cover these people, for so many reasons it is ludicrous to list. The simple fact is that we are at war with these people, and they will not let up. Ask Daniel Pearl how they treated him.
Fairy tale one: if we follow the Army Field Manual, they will treat our people better. This didn't happen with the Japanese, the Koreans, the Viet Cong or the Iraqis in the first Gulf War. It certainly hasn't been the case with Al Queda.
Fairy tale two: these techniques don't work- the victims will say anything to make it stop. This is absolute, unmitigated bunk. The twentieth century was a dirty world with this stuff, and the KGB, CIA, M6 and Mossad did not work these things out without getting any verifiable results. I have been told that many of the still classified reports about the early Al Queda interrogations provided a bounty of verifiable information.
Fairy tale three: if we turn our guns first on the political opposition here, the jihadists will see that we have truly reformed and drop their aggression towards us. Their jihad is not based on any of this, and will not be ameliorated by Obama going on Al Jezzera and making nice. They want us off the planet because we are heathens who live decadent lifestyles. Killing us is their ticket to heaven. Are we all clear on that?
When we captured them after 9/11, and went past the FBI investigators and actually made them feel like they were in danger, it set them off balance. If they lose that fear of us, we have a problem.
I am a libertarian at heart, and I fully understand the Constitution and it's implications in this. But the Constitution is NOT a suicide pact, and these people need to be hit- hard. If I suspect that some of them are holding information about an impending American attack, I will be happy to personally provide the car battery, some cables and a nice bucket of wet sponges. If what we do does not result in some serious pupil dilation on their part, we may as well let them loose.
Which, come to think of it, is exactly what this White House is talking about doing. It's possible they just don't think we are at war. Worse, they may well know we are, and think this is the way to win it.
With that, who the hell should be prosecuting who around here?